

1601
N. Tucson Blvd. Suite 9
Tucson, AZ 85716-3450
Phone: (800) 635-1196
Hotline: (800) 419-4777
|
Association
of American Physicians and Surgeons, Inc.
A Voice for Private Physicians Since 1943
Omnia pro aegroto |
HOW TO RECOGNIZE A COERCIVE AND RESTRICTIVE HEALTH
PLAN
(These limitations of patients' rights are common to most managed care plans.)
- It restricts your choice of doctors and sometimes hospitals.
- To be one of its doctors, the physician becomes ``capitated,'' or salaried by the insurance
company, depending on how many people sign up to go under his care. You and your
illness now become, in effect, a liability to your doctor. Your sickness becomes his
expense.
- Your doctor is rewarded by an end-of-year bonus, for how much he or she saves the
insurance company. Referrals to specialists and lab studies comes out of your doctor's
own income.
- If your doctor spends too much on your care, he or she may be dropped from the list at ANY
TIME. This is called being ``deselected.'' The HMO does not have to give a reason.
- Limited appeal: Your doctor can only appeal to the insurance company. He or she is denied
an impartial third-party arbiter.
- GAG RULE: Any criticism of the plan by one of the doctors may result in deselection (a
feature of some contracts).
- Restricted and cumbersome specialty referrals: The plan requires that the primary doctor
receive approval from the insurance company before making referrals to specialists. This
is a very time-consuming and costly process that must be paid for by the doctor. He
might be tempted to forgo your referral.
- The plan discourages out-of-network (unbiased) care by setting high extra fees to be paid by
you.
- The cost of the system is hidden. Actual premium costs may not be available to the patient.
Instead, there is emphasis on the low office co-payment. Try asking your employer how
much he pays for your care.
- Encouragement of ``vertically integrated care'': Every ``provider,'' from the hospital to the
pharmacist to the physician, benefits financially when care is limited. Those who refuse
to cooperate, for moral reasons, will be excluded from the plan.
Such a system is NOT INSURANCE, BUT A SYSTEM OF COERCION, which meddles in the
patient-physician relationship for profit. Any company that places its employees in such a plan
and any doctor who participates may subject the worker/patient to potential abuse.
FREEDOM IN MEDICINE IS EVERYONE'S RESPONSIBILITY. There is an alternative that
will make medical care more accessible and affordable, with complete freedom of choice:
Medical Savings Accounts combined with high-deductible insurance. For information, call
AAPS, (800)635-1196.
List prepared by Drs. John and Alieta Eck, Affordable Health, Inc., Somerset, NJ, (908)562-
0033. |