Category Archives: mythbusters

Doctors Sue to Overturn the Health Care Bill

The Association of American Physicians and Surgeons (AAPS) became the first medical society to sue to overturn the newly enacted health care bill, the Patient Protection and Affordable Care Act (PPACA). AAPS sued Friday in the U.S. District Court for … Continue reading

Posted in AAPS v Sebelius, mythbusters | 38 Comments

Myth 33. Reducing geographic disparities will reduce spending without sacrificing quality.

The cure for excessive U.S. medical spending, according to prominent academics as well as Peter Orszag, director of the Office of Management and Budget (OMB), is called the “30% solution.” Its basis is the Dartmouth Atlas, produced by the Dartmouth … Continue reading

Posted in mythbusters | 4 Comments

Myth 32. Information technology will improve efficiency and safety.

A large part of the savings projected from “healthcare reform” is supposed to come from wider use of information technology. The federal government is expected to “invest” some $45 billion in encouraging (or compelling) doctors and hospitals to use electronic … Continue reading

Posted in information technology, mythbusters | 23 Comments

Myth 31. “Healthcare reform” bills will increase doctors’ pay while “saving” nearly half a trillion Medicare dollars.

Legislation heavily promoted by the AMA and passed by the House of Representatives, H.R. 3961, would eliminate the 21% scheduled Medicare pay cut for doctors required by the sustained growth rate (SGR) formula. Yearly last-minute reprieves have postponed the cuts … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 2 Comments

Myth 30. Healthcare reform is not “socialized medicine.”

Many critics of the Democrats’ “healthcare reform” call it “socialized medicine.” Advocates respond, condescendingly, that since the government would not own the means of production, and physicians would not be salaried by the American equivalent of the British National Health … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters, socialized medicine | 14 Comments

Myth 29. Health care reform will not increase abortions or lead to federal funding of abortion—or of other parts of a radical social agenda.

The Democrat’s reform plans would have a powerful ally—the Roman Catholic Church and its huge network of hospitals—were it not for the perception that plans as currently drafted would permit taxpayer funding of abortions. Without the Stupak Amendment, legislation probably … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 1 Comment

Myth 28. Healthcare reform bills will not cover illegal aliens.

The growing number of “48 million uninsured” includes perhaps 15 million illegal aliens (Phoenix Business Journal 7/22/09). Obama’s statement that “ the reforms I’m proposing would not apply to those who are here illegally” elicited the notorious “You lie” outburst … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | Leave a comment

Myth 27. Healthcare reform is affordable.

Calling something affordable, even in the title, doesn’t make it so. Making somebody else pay the bill doesn’t make it affordable either. A massive redistribution scheme adds costs, and makes the total cost less affordable.

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 3 Comments

Myth 26. Government-directed rationing will be rational.

It all sounds very reasonable: to set priorities, to use the most effective therapies, to serve the neediest first. Rationing is a given, say reform advocates. Insurance companies already do it. Let’s just make it rational and fair. Some say … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 3 Comments

Myth 25. Medical care costs too much because private corporations make a profit.

In his address to Congress on health care reform, Barack Obama cited Alabama as a state in which almost 90% of health insurance is controlled by one company. “[A]n additional step we can take to keep insurance companies honest is … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 5 Comments

Myth 24. Medicare is the model of efficiency and fairness.

Medicare is immensely popular, has very low administrative costs, is already a working model,… it is said: Why not just have Medicare for all? At one time, calling Medicare “socialized medicine for the elderly” caused stunned silence in the Congress. … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, medicare, mythbusters | 12 Comments

Myth 23. Private insurance and self-payment are relics of an oppressive past, confined to the United States and backwater, poorly developed nations.

We constantly hear that the United States is the only nation in the “developed,” or “industrialized” world (we no longer say “civilized” world or “free” world) that doesn’t have taxpayer-funded medical care for all.

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 2 Comments

Myth 22. “Health care reform” is a moral imperative.

In a telephone call to clergymen, also broadcast over the internet, Obama dismissed the concerns of opponents of his health agenda as “fabrications.” Dissenters were making up allegations about death panels, government funding of abortions, and a government takeover of … Continue reading

Posted in Uncategorized, health care reform, mythbusters | 12 Comments

Myth 21. Proposed health care reform would offer more choices.

White House spokesman Robert Gibbs used the phrase “choice and competition” three times, and variations on the words “choice” and “competition” five times each, in a 1 minute, 10 second interview with CBS’s Face the Nation, noted Mike Gonzalez. That … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 3 Comments

Myth 20. Doctors, not bureaucrats, make decisions in national health systems.

Obama has promised that doctors, not bureaucrats, will be making the decisions under his “health care reform” plan. If Obama’s promise is true, why do central planners need extensive data on every encounter with every patient?

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 12 Comments

Myth 19: The American people are demanding “health care now.”

Spokesmen for the Democrats’ “health care reform” proposals say that all those ordinary-appearing Americans waving hand-made signs are either operatives of powerful vested interests, especially insurance companies, or “political enemies” bent on destroying the Obama presidency.

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 2 Comments

Myth 18: Proposed health care reform will not hasten the death of seniors, cancer patients, and disabled persons.

The phrase “death panel” does not actually occur in any of the proposed “health care reform” bills. MoveOn.org has seized on Sarah Palin’s characterization of the outcome of “reform” in its mass email piece entitled “Top Five Health Care Reform … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, medical ethics, mythbusters, socialized medicine | 8 Comments

Myth 17: Health care reform will establish a right to health care.

Everybody in a country with “universal health care” has a “right” to health care, but Americans do not—or so it is argued. “Health care reform” is supposed to correct a moral deficiency in the United States, and, at long last, … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 7 Comments

Myth 16. In countries with government-funded health care, people get immediate care in emergencies, though they may have to wait for elective procedures.

The usual response to concerns about the months-long waiting lists for surgery in Canada and Britain is that this is a mere inconvenience, a small price to pay for universal “free” care. If you have a really serious need, you’ll … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters, single payer health care, socialized medicine, universal care | 9 Comments

Myth 15. Nationalized medicine will reduce medical errors, improve care, and save lives.

Based on 173 deaths in the Harvard Medical Practice study, and extrapolating to the entire U.S. population, the Institute of Medicine (IOM) has been claiming for almost a decade that as many as 98,000 Americans are killed by medical errors … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, medical errors, mythbusters | 4 Comments

Myth 14: We must choose between the “status quo” and the Democrats’ “reform” plan

The strategy during the August recess was outlined by Paul Begala, a Democrat strategist close to the White House: “Supporters of reform have to put the status quo on trial” (Politico.com 7/26/09).

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 8 Comments

Myth 13. “Health care reform” is being enacted through a democratic process.

If “democracy” means a nationally televised speech by the Leader, the expenditure of tens of millions of dollars by pressure groups, and a frenzied process of voting on a short deadline, then this is a Democratic process—with a capital “D” … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 4 Comments

Myth 12. The uninsured cause overcrowding in emergency rooms, and increase costs for the “rest of us” through cost-shifting.

The uninsured are frequently vilified as “free riders” who receive care but shift the cost onto others—when they are not being portrayed as victims who don’t get as much medical care as some think they should.

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters, uninsured | 4 Comments

Myth 11. There are 46 million or more Americans without “health care.”

No one, to our knowledge, has actually come up with an estimate of the number of residents in America, legal or illegal, who are denied life-saving medical care—if indeed there are any. Even accusations of violating EMTALA—the Emergency Medical Treatment … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters, uninsured | 9 Comments

Myth 10. If you like your health plan and your doctor, you can keep them.

The reason that the President needs to promise that he won’t take away your health plan or your doctor is that he believes that he could. After all, there is no right to choose a doctor or form of payment … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 9 Comments

Myth 9. A “public option” is needed to spur competition, keep private plans honest, and bring down costs.

The White House claims that the choice of a public plan operating alongside private plans would spur private plans to improve. It also promises that all plans would be playing by the same rules.

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 5 Comments

Myth 8. Spending more on prevention and “wellness” will enable us to spend less on medical care while improving health.

The idea of having a “wellness” rather than a “disease” orientation is politically appealing, and politicians on both sides of the aisle promise painless savings of “billions” by “incenting doctors” to “keep people healthy.”

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 5 Comments

Myth 7. Universal coverage, enforced through an individual mandate, as in Massachusetts, will achieve universal access and reduce costs.

According to the implicit hypothesis underlying the rush to “health care reform,” the main barrier to ideal care for all at an affordable cost is the absence of universal “coverage”—payment and supervision—by an appropriate (governmental or government-credentialed) third party.

Posted in health care reform, mandatory insurance, mythbusters, universal care | 10 Comments

Myth 6: Life expectancy is longer in other countries because they have universal tax-funded medical coverage, and the U.S. does not.

The longest-lived people are probably the Japanese. They have good genes, are seldom overweight, and eat lots of fish. They have had a government-funded medical system since 1927—and they also have a robust private medical sector. Japanese, like all people … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters, single payer health care, universal care | 5 Comments

Myth 5. Cost control and quality will emerge from comparative effectiveness research.

Congress appropriated $1.1 billion—the total worth of 1,100 millionaires—to “comparative effectiveness research” (CER). It promised that CER would not turn out to be “cost-effectiveness research”—and the rationale for treatment rationing and denial—although it defeated a proposed amendment that would have … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | Tagged | 12 Comments

Myth 4: Infant mortality is lower in other countries because they have “universal” tax-funded medical care, and the U.S. does not.

A number of countries report lower infant mortality than the U.S., but it has nothing to do with the source of payment for medical care.

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters, single payer health care, socialized medicine, universal care | Leave a comment

Myth 3. Americans are going bankrupt, and American companies are noncompetitive, because we don’t have “universal health care.”

For years, advocates of “single payer health care” have been warning that middle-class Americans are only “one serious illness away from bankruptcy”—even if they have insurance. Obama has claimed that medical costs cause a bankruptcy in America every 30 seconds. … Continue reading

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | Tagged | 14 Comments

Myth 2: A public plan could save enough on administrative costs to provide coverage to all.

It is frequently asserted, especially by groups such as Physicians for a National Health Program (PNHP), that a “single payer” (government) system could “save” enough money on administration to buy coverage for all the uninsured.

Posted in health care reform, mythbusters | 9 Comments

Myth 1: An electronic medical record could save your life in an emergency

Information technology does not stop bleeding, start IVs, defibrillate the heart, or put in a breathing tube. In an emergency, those are the things that save your life. If you need them, the doctor does not have time to look … Continue reading

Posted in information technology, mythbusters | 13 Comments